JORIS IVENS AND HANNS EISLER - FILM AND MUSIC
(in Kaze—A Joris Ivens Retrospective, YIDFF, 1999)

Kees Bakker

 

Joris Ivens and Hanns Eisler were both born in 1898; 'a good wine year' Ivens once said, for Eisenstein and Brecht were also born in that year. There are several similarities between the carreers of Eisler and Ivens: both not always welcome in their homelands, and both their works not always respected because of their communist sympathies. They met each other in the twenties in the cultural Mecca of Europe of that time: Berlin.


In 1932, Ivens asked Eisler to come to Magnitogorsk to write the music and produce the soundtrack for the film Song of Heroes; an ode to the work of the Komsomol youth to build blast furnaces and towns in the steppes of the Oural. This became one of the first elaborate soundtracks for a documentary film, made by a composer. Who better than Eisler can describe the work he had to do:

I saw directly that I could not make the music from behind my desk, so I started as a 'musical reporter'. I first needed information on the realization and its details, then record the original music of the national minorities, and the sounds in the factories. The work was not easy for me - who had not the habit to climb up like a mechanic on te top of a blast furnace to be able to find the good place for the best sound of this enormous uproar - so I am always very proud to have recorded more than seven-hundred and fifteen meters of noises and national minorities musics in a very unusual atmosphere for me. The second stage of my work was done in Moscow, where I composed the music of the film, which I recorded at the Mezjrabom studios. First, with comrade Tretjakov, I composed the 'Ballad of Magnitogorsk' of the Komsomol. The text was very simple:

Oural, Oural,
City of the Magnet Mountain,
There is much steel.
The Party says:
Give us … steel!
The Komsomols answer:
Within the ordered time,
We will give you steel!

Eisler and Ivens had the same ideologies, and both liked to drink, so they became close friends. Their friendship resulted in a few other collaborations. In 1934, Ivens had elaborated the film Zuiderzee, on the reclamation of polderland from the see, to give it a political, anti capitalist, message. He asked Eisler to compose the music for this documentary. The most famous sequence of this film is the closing of the dyke: in which the best qualities of Joris Ivens, Helen van Dongen (who did the editing), and Hanns Eisler are combined, resulting in a haunting montage sequence of powerful images accompanied by stirring music.

In 1936 Ivens went to the United States. Eisler came in 1938, exiled from his homeland. In 1938 Ivens went to China to film The 400 Million. The last film for which he asked Eisler to compose the music, and the first documentary in which twelve tone music is used. But Eisler writes music for yet another film of Ivens; this time it is Eisler who askes Ivens, in 1941, not if Ivens wants to make a film to accompany his music, but it he may use the film Rain (1929) for his 'Film Music Project' at the New School of Social Research in New York. The chambermusic piece that stems from this project is Eisler's 'Fourteen Ways to Describe Rain' - a beautiful piece of music, and a beautiful film, however, together it is not the best match. Instead of talking about music for the film Rain, it is better to state that Eisler's music is 'inspired by the film'; only the fact that the music is two minutes longer than the film says enough. But, looking at their common work, the combination of the film-maker and the composer has proven to be very fruitful and powerful.

 

Interesting links:

Internationale Hanns Eisler Gesellschaft

eislermusic.com

 

Home
Home